The Poetics of an Enlightenment Rivalry
In 1740, the diplomat and writer Hubert Le Blanc published his celebrated treatise defending the French basse de viole against the growing "pretensions" of the italian violoncello. Now seen as a sort of caricature of the two instruments, this controversy reflected a profound transformation in European musical taste, marking a debate between the viola da gamba's refined aristocratic tradition and a new aesthetic that embraced the Italian language of the violoncello and the expressive ideals of the emerging modern style.
Basses Reunited revisits this historic quarrel through works by Sainte-Colombe, Marin Marais, Domenico Gabrielli, Carl Friedrich Abel, Johann Sebastian Bach, Giuseppe Clemente Dall'Abaco, and Jean-Baptiste Barrière. The program presents two contrasting musical worlds in which the viola da gamba and the violoncello engage in dialogue, challenge one another, and ultimately reveal their complementarity.
Inspired by the rhetoric of the Enlightenment, the concert unfolds as a series of musical debates, inviting audiences to appreciate the differences between these two instruments without reducing them to a contest. Eloquence and intimacy, memory and innovation, subtlety and strength emerge as complementary aesthetic values, demonstrating how contrast itself can become a source of imagination, expression, and beauty.
Archivo visual: Marly Juliana Torres
Exordium – The Eloquence of Beauty
Marin Marais, Première Suite, I Livre
First Debate – An Affair between States
France vs. Italy
Sainte-Colombe, Chaconne
vs.
Domenico Gabrielli, Sonata No. 1
Second Debate – Two Generations in Conflict
The Subtlety of Tradition vs. Modern Virtuosity
Carl Friedrich Abel, Arpeggio
vs.
Johann Sebastian Bach, Suite No. 3 BWV 1009
Third Debate – The Enlightenment's Dilemma
Emotion vs. Reason
Carl Friedrich Abel, Andante
vs.
Giuseppe Clément Dall'Abaco, Caprice No. 1
Verdict – A Reconciliation
A Frenchman Writing in Italian
Jean-Baptiste Barrière, Sonata No. 1, I Livre
10 de julio, 2026
5:00 p.m.
Iglesia San Ignacio
Bogotá
24 de julio, 2026
7:00 p.m.
Paraninfo Universidad de Antioquia
Medellín